Tag Archives: safety

Are You Safer in Mexico or America?

Should I travel to Mexico?  Is it safe?  What about Oaxaca?  Robert Reid, Lonely Planet’s US travel editor wrote a blog post on May 10, 2012 about safety in Mexico, offering six reasons why Mexico is safe.  The headline is Are You Safer in Mexico or America?  The Huffington Post picked it up and published it and our follower, Bruce Anderson sent the story my way.  Thanks, Bruce!

I’m going to start with Reid’s last two points, which are specific to Oaxaca.  I am constantly writing about safety here because one of the biggest myths circulating is that travel to Mexico is not safe and safety is one of the most popular search terms on my blog.  I am on a mission.  It is my number one pet peeve.  The traveling public needs to know that most tourist destinations in Mexico — and especially Oaxaca — are safe.

Help me spread the word by forwarding this to one friend who is skeptical! Here’s what Reid says . . .

5. Malia Obama ignored the Texas advice.

Of all people, President Obama and first lady said “OK” to their 13-year-old daughter’s spring break destination this year: Oaxaca. Then Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum made snide remarks over that, perhaps overlooking that Oaxaca state has a smaller body count from the drug war than his home state’s murder rate (Oaxaca’s 4.39 per 100,000 to Pennsylvania’s 5.2).

Oaxaca state, not on the US travel warning, is famed for its colonial city, Zapotec ruins and emerging beach destinations like Huatulco. Lonely Planet author Greg Benchwick even tried grasshoppers with the local mezcal (Malia apparently stuck with vanilla shakes.)

So, can you go to Mexico?

Yes. As the US State Department says, “millions of US citizens safely visit Mexico each year.” Last year, when I took on the subject for CNN, one commenter suggested Lonely Planet was being paid to promote travel there. No we weren’t. We took on the subject simply because – as travelers so often know – there is another story beyond the perception back home, be it Vietnam welcoming Americans in the ’90s or Colombia’s dramatic safety improvements in the ’00s. And, equally as importantly, Mexico makes for some of the world’s greatest travel experiences – it’s honestly why I’m in this line of work.

So yes, you can go to Mexico, just as you can go to Texas, or New Orleans, or Orlando, or the Bahamas. It’s simply up to you to decide whether you want to.

Robert Reid is Lonely Planet’s US Travel Editor and has been going to Mexico since he was three (most recently to Chacala).

Was Malia Obama in Teotitlan del Valle, Oaxaca today?

I am going to posit a guess that Malia Obama was in Teotitlan del Valle, Oaxaca today with her classmates.  It was three o’clock in the afternoon and Pedro Montaño Lorenzo and I were on our way out-of-town heading to Matatlan in search of El Cortijo mezcal.  Pedro had just asked me if I thought Malia would visit Teotitlan.  It wasn’t on her itinerary, I said.  No, I don’t think so.  Just then, we passed a house where I saw a lot of activity — much more than usual.

It had to have been the U.S. Secret Service entourage I saw parked in front the house of weavers Victor and Rafaela today.  Why else would there be thirty vehicles in front of a small weaving house?  Why else would there be Mexican Federal Police cars parked beside them?  Why else would there be a truckload of armed military men of the Army of Mexico parked at the Crucero — where the road to Teotitlan connects to the Pan-American Highway?  There were probably four or five Federales cars roaming the road, too.  And, I couldn’t take a photo or I might have been thrown in jail!  And, I wanted to turn around and go back to say, “Hi, welcome to Oaxaca.”  But, I knew they wouldn’t take to kindly on that!

I turned my head to look at the doorway of the house, which was packed with people.  Yep, I thought.  Malia Obama made it to Teotitlan del Valle. She will know about the centuries old tradition of tapestry loom weaving that makes this village so special.

Is the U.S. Media Complicit? Feeding the Fear Frenzy About Travel to Mexico

We are having an on-going discussion among friends who live in Mexico and in the U.S. about whether the news media in the U.S. is complicit in creating fear about travel to Mexico.

On March 18, 2012, The New York Times published a story about kidnappings in Matamoros, that borders the U.S.  The headline was: “In Mexico, a Kidnapping Ignored as Crime Worsens.”  I wrote to Damien Cave, The New York Times Bureau Chief in Mexico City, responsible for the story, complaining about the headline.  Here is our series of replies, most recent one first:

It’s an accurate headline and impunity is a problem all over Mexico not just in Matamoros. If you don’t like that fact take it up with the Mexican gov not me. I live here too – I get your complaint and I’m writing a travel story about Mazunte soon – but the bottom line is Mexico needs to fix its judicial system. Now. (see my footnote below**)
Damien Cave
The New York Times

Enviado desde mi iPhone

On 18/03/2012, at 11:49 a.m., Norma Hawthorne <normahawthorne@mac.com> wrote:
Sorry, Damien.  I don’t agree with you.  Using Mexico in the headline instead of Matamoros implies that the story is universally applied to all of Mexico.  As the NY Times bureau chief, you should do better.  And, all readers are “not smart enough.”  You are the 5th estate.  It is your responsibility to educate not inflame.  Norma Hawthorne
On Mar 18, 2012, at 01:41 PM, Damien Cave <cave.damien@gmail.com> wrote:
Oaxaca has a 99.74% impunity rate – so while crime is not as epidemic there as elsewhere the crimes that do happen are just as unlikely to lead to punishment. I love Oaxaca but it is not place devoid of Mexicos larger problems. Our readers are also smart enough to know that my story is the story of one city not the country and if you had taken the time to look at other stories I’ve written (look up my story about immigration to Oaxaxa) you would understand that as well. Damien Cave
The New York Times  Enviado desde mi iPhoneOn 18/03/2012, at 11:29 a.m., <ordercs@nytimes.com> wrote:
Email: normahawthorne@mac.com
URL:In Mexico, As Kidnapping Ignored Crimes Worsen
Comments: Damien, this headline is incorrect and irresponsible sensational journalism. It implies that kidnapping and crime is rampant throughout Mexico. This story is localized in Matamoros, a border town. What you are promoting is fear of travel to Mexico. Most of Mexico, including Oaxaca where I live, is safe. PLEASE revisit your approach and those of other NYTimes reporters to make sensationalized headlines. It is poor reporting and does a disservice to accuracy about travel to Mexico. Sincerely, Norma Hawthorne, oaxacaculture.com

On March 14, 2012, a CNN web page published a report with the headine, “No End to Mexico Violence.”

Friend and photography instructor Frances “Sam” Robbins, who teaches our Oaxaca Photography Workshop–Market Towns and Artisan Villages, responded:

“It would be so much better if your headlines specified WHERE in Mexico the violence is happening.  There are still wonderful, very safe places for people to live, to visit and to enjoy.  Referring to the whole of Mexico in a headline with the word violence continues to build a sense of fear for the entire country.  That’s just wrong.”

Perhaps as a result of Sam’s comment, CNN changed it’s headline banner to read:
Violence in Juarez ‘not going away’.  Sam emailed me to say she was thankful that someone on the editorial staff was responsive.  But that’s not always the case.

My sister Barbara and I just completed a week-long, public bus trip around the states of Puebla and Tlaxcala.  I traveled from Oaxaca on the ADO bus — solo.  She landed in the Mexico City airport from San Francisco, California, got on an Estrella Roja bus to Puebla and met me there.  The next day, we were the only gringas on the bus to Cuetzalan.  From there, we bought a one-way ticket to Huamantla, where we transferred to a collectivo to Tlaxcala.  In Tlaxcala, we hired a taxi driver on the street to take us on a round trip to a Olmec archeological site.  The next day we traveled back to Puebla on a local collectivo bus.  Again, we were the only foreigners.

Never, during this travel experience, did we feel threatened, at risk, or in fear of our safety or security.  Local people were always helpful and wanting to give us directions or asking if we needed advice. When it rained and the streets were slippery in Cuetzalan, men came up to offer their hand to help us across the street or down a steep stairway.  Their extended arms are a symbol of welcome and warmth.

The Washington Post published a December 2011 feature on where it is safe to travel in Mexico and where it isn’t.  This is a MUST read.

So, I’ve been thinking about why it is that there is so much fear by Estadounidenses (people from the United States) about traveling to Mexico, beyond what might be reasonable or rational.

All your comments about this important issue are welcome.

**Footnote:  Sweeping generalizations tend to grip our sensibilities and bypass reasonable thinking. We forget that random, isolated incidences of violence occur everywhere.  Our own judicial system has broken down, too. I think of all the criminals out on parole because the prison system doesn’t work, is overloaded, and the parole system is lax. Case in point: The murder of Eve Carson, student body president at UNC Chapel Hill by a convict out on parole who shouldn’t have been.

 

 

 

Oaxaca: Beauty is Everywhere — And It’s Safe, Too

Oaxaca is beautiful and safe, says Elliot Stoller, who visited in December 2011.  He recently wrote to me and ordered the self-guided tour map of Teotitlan del Valle to prepare for his trip next year.  Elliot’s photos are so beautiful that I want to share them with you (with his permission, of course).  And his testimonial about safety deserves attention.

Oaxaca: Beauty is Everywhere

Oaxaca: Night of the Radishes

Oaxaca: Mitla

” I felt as safe in Oaxaca as I feel in any city in the USA. The people are friendly and helpful. In fact, in the evenings, I felt safer in Oaxaca than I do in Seattle because there were so many people out and about… socializing, eating at sidewalk cafes, watching performances of folk dancers or taking part in Las Posadas (religious processions) and enjoying the wonderful weather.

Oaxaca: Chocolate

Oaxaca: Rodolfo Morales Museum, Ocotlan de Morelos

“I know about 40 words of Spanish but I always found that the Oaxaca people would be patient and we found a way to communicate. Once, I was in a restaurant and I couldn’t read the menu. I was trying to order tortillas with different fillings. The cook motioned for me to come up to where everything was cooking and she took off the pot lids so I could point at the fillings I wanted.

Oaxaca: Ethnobotanical Garden

Oaxaca: Monte Alban

“A guide we hired took us to Teotitlan Del Valle but we stopped at only one workshop/home. I returned to Teotitlan on the Fundacion En Via tour (a non-profit that fights poverty through micro-finance) so I was able so see more of the town and a more realistic picture of the townspeople.

Oaxaca: The Churches

“I love Oaxaca. I plan to go back again in December  this year for two more weeks. And I’m fantasizing about retiring there. I fell in love with Oaxaca as you can probably tell from my photographs.

“Thank you for your wonderful blog,”

Elliot Stoller,  Seattle, Washington

***

Upcoming photography workshops in Oaxaca:  Portrait Photography, Market Towns and Artisan Villages, and Day of the Dead

 

Yaxchilan: Remote Mayan Site in Chiapas Jungle–Get There By Boat!

 

Yaxchilan (Yash-chee-lahn) is situated on the high banks of the Usumacinta River that borders Mexico and Guatemala, three hours southeast of Palenque.  The secluded ruins are in a dense jungle only accessible by river boat, a good 30-minute ride from the launch site.  The boat ride is a wonderful transition from now to then.  In years past, Lacandon Mayas made this passage in open dugout canoes.  Today, the wood-planked boats are covered in palm thatch.

  

Alligator or crocodile?

 

Yaxchilan rivaled Palenque (Mexico) and Tikal (Guatemala) as these three “super-powers” vied for control over the surrounding lesser Mayan centers that provided food, tribute and able fighters.

This magnificent archeological site is worthy of several hours of your time.  It is a space that is dark jungle, moss-covered, limestone rocks tumbled and crumbling, and with only the beginnings of a restoration in process.

 

As you walk into the space you feel as if you were an archeologist discovering it for the first time. It speaks of antiquity.  The howler monkeys calling back and forth across the river are haunting, adding a sense of mystery to the place. I pass through a compact Mayan arch into a vast plaza.

 

Situated high on a river bank, the site offers a strategic location on the wide and magnificent Usumacinta River, testifying to the power and influence of this once-great city.   Huge bromeliads hang from hundred foot high trees with mahogany colored trunks.  I walk beneath a tall canopy of leaves, vines, roots and flowering succulents, careful not to trip on toppled stones.

 

 

Yaxchilan is probably like Palenque was 30 years ago.  The only nearby lodging is at the boat launch site, where there are also a couple of good restaurants.  If you contact Daniel Chank In, the Selva Lacandon guide, he can help you make lodging and boat travel arrangements instead of taking the cookie-cutter day trip.

My journal scrawlings about the Palenque to Yaxchilan passage:

The languages of travel are Czech, German, three varieties of English (Brit, American, Aussie), Spanish, French, Dutch. These are my traveling companions. In Palenque they speak Chol. We stopped for breakfast at a simple comedor with tree trunks for stools and a dirt floor and GREAT coffee, dark and rich, locally grown and organic.  I have not been sick since I arrived in Mexico a month ago.

We are western women taught to cover our breasts, be modest. From the window of the van I see a woman at the water source, one large breast exposed, suspended, full of milk walking toward a toddler waiting for nourishment.  Plank wood and palm thatch cover the humans at night.  Shelter is simple for man, woman, cows, chickens.  Chiapas, siempre verde is the state motto.  It is always damp here.  We are on flat land now, clear-cut for growing corn and lumbering, heading toward the frontier.  Maize scrabble, hard-scrabble, bare feet, dirt, bare chests, men at work with machetes.  We pass a sign: This is Zapatista country.  Land of campesinos.

Grazing land, cattle, horses.  Ceiba trees, overcast skies, animals are thin I see their bones.  We pass through pueblos of resistance, a village sign announces this, the sign is rough wood with white paint. The land is flat, vast, green scrub.  This is the road to the Guatemala border.  We pass military sentries, checkpoints, men heavily armed, some masked.  Put your cameras down and cell phones away, says the driver, as we approach one. They wave us through.  On the way back, away from the border, we are stopped and I show my passport.  Of course they are checking for drugs and I know that the pipeline works its way across the river through the jungle to the vast cities and towns of America where demand keeps this business in business.  Did I feel in danger?  No.